About Us

Offering the Best Rates & Service in Professional Liability Insurance

Sam Cohen

Owner & President
(727) 799-4321

Sam Cohen, President of Attorneys First Insurance & Agent, was born and raised in Ansonia, Connecticut. Sam Cohen is a 1975 graduate of Princeton University; he has lived in the Tampa Bay Area since 1989. Sam worked as an agent for an independent insurance agency in Florida for five years prior to opening Attorneys First Insurance and providing Professional Liability Insurance in December 2003.

Debra Prendergast

Operations Manager & Agent
(727) 559-2999

Debra joined Attorneys First Insurance in 2019. She recently relocated from the Jersey Shore to the Tampa Bay Area. Debra offers clients over ten years of experience in the insurance industry. She specializes in Legal Malpractice Insurance. Title Agents Errors & Omissions, Cyber & Crime and Title Agents Fidelity and Surety Bonds. In her free time she enjoys biking on the Pinellas Trail, paddle boarding and yoga.


Click Here to get a Premium Estimate for your Professional Liability Insurance Today!


Contact Us Today!

Sam Cohen:
Email: Sam@AttorneysFirst.com

Debra Prendergast:
Email: Debbie@AttorneysFirst.com

FAX: 727-499-6829

Client Reviews!